Register   Login
 Search   
My Resources  

Lewis Ranch HP
Discussion Forums  
New ThreadMy SettingsMy PostsSearchForum Home
  Topics  Unwanted Horse Issue  Unwanted horse ...
 Re: Unwanted horse issue - your thoughts
 
 6/18/2008 6:35:12 PM
ClassAct
12 posts


Re: Unwanted horse issue - your thoughts
QuoteReply

The glut of unwanted horses has not been proven. There are stories attempting to prove this. Skewed reports capitalizing on the emotional interest . The foreign -owned slaughter plants provided little economically to the locality, whereas, rendering houses are better business. Furthermore, horse meat should be rendered into healthier dog foods making a healthier product available for less to average dog owners.

Instead the commodities driven corn glut and the meat-by-products business, chemicals and fillers now passing for supermarket dog food are a scam. Pet food manufacturers are not highly regulated, it's a business for unloading low grade corn into the market. Horse meat would make better sense given that Americans don't have a pallet for it.

The economic side of the opposition to horse slaughter is ignored by pro-slaughter proponents. By labelling it an emotional issue the pro-slaughter interests paint a one-sided picture, using emotional content, such as; A. there is a glut of horses, B. pro-slaughter people are emotional but we are not.

The stories of unwanted horses when investigated further are inaccurate.

 8/5/2008 10:30:16 PM
sensiblehorses
2 posts


Re: Unwanted horse issue - your thoughts
QuoteReply

I'm afraid that's a little bit of wishful thinking ClassAct. When a registered yearling with no defects routinely brings $75. at auction I think that means there are unwanted horses. When slaughter houses were in operation, common horses sold for three times their present market value. To my knowledge rendering companies pay nothing and actually charge a lot of money to pick up animals. I am saddened when a horse is put down. But it seems that slaughter is as humane as anything else and probably more so. And the economics are definitely there for the owner. And in A free society the owner should be the one that makes that decision, not someone else who does not know the individual circumstances.

  Topics  Unwanted Horse Issue  Unwanted horse ...
  Copyright 2007 by IMI Global
Terms Of Use   Privacy Statement